What’s the Best Garbage Disposal? Top 5 Revealed


Feb 21
garbage disposal

At some point in your life, you’ve probably had a kitchen sink sans garbage disposal. And it probably was a huge pain, right?

Doing the dishes without a garbage disposal can get flat out nasty.

All of the food scraps from your pots, pans and plates get mushed together in the drain plug and then you have to dig it all out by hand so you don’t have to pay a plumber to come unclog your pipes later.

Ok, we know that there are worse things in the world than having to clean out your sink by hand – but you can’t deny that the wet, slimy food mush does not feel great in your fingers.

room full of garbage

(Also, it kind of makes us not want to eat our leftovers).

Well, thank goodness most modern kitchens have sinks equipped with garbage disposals.

A garbage disposal may not seem like the most exciting parts of your kitchen, but once you have one you come to realize that they are truly magical contraptions.

So, if you don’t have a garbage disposal, don’t you think it’s time to make the investment?

Why You Need a Garbage Disposal

Where should we start?

There are plenty of great reasons to get a garbage disposal. Yes, you can certainly survive without one –but the practical benefits of having one certainly make it a good addition to any kitchen.

For one, it provides effective food waste disposal, and sometimes that food waste can be turned into other resources. Plus, it means that less food waste is ending up in landfills.

Of course, clean up after meals becomes much easier when you have a garbage disposal at your… disposal (sorry, we had to).

Grinding up your food scraps in the sink means that you aren’t risking clogging your pipes (though it is possible for garbage disposals to get clogged) and you are putting less waste into the trashcan. And less waste in the trash can means you don’t have to empty it as often!

And, like we said before, you don’t have to touch any of your soggy food scraps if you have a garbage disposal.

Another great aspect of garbage disposals is that they don’t actually cost that much to use each year because they don’t require much water.

So, the reasons to get one are ample. But that doesn’t mean you should get just any old garbage disposal.

A garbage disposal should be an investment for your home, and it’s never a good idea to go for the cheapest option. Rather, you should search for a high-quality appliance that will last many years and potentially add value to your home.

That’s why we put together a list of the best garbage disposals. We want to help you make an informed purchase – especially considering you’ll probably use it every single day.

​How We Chose Our Ratings

In looking for the best garbage disposals, we kept a close eye both on features and reviews from people who have bought and used them.

In terms of the features, we wanted to pick ones that included some basics that everyone should look for in a garbage disposal.

First of all, the motor of your garbage disposal should be powerful enough to slash through all types of food waste and avoid any jams. A garbage disposal with higher horsepower will generally run a lot smoother and make your life easier.

We also picked disposals that have durable grinding chambers big enough to handle larger volumes of food waste, and that don’t make too much noise. Loud noise is inevitable when it comes to garbage disposals, but the best ones don’t get bloodcurdlingly loud.

Lastly, we looked for other advantageous features like auto-reverse so the motor can reverse its rotation when something gets stuck in the grinding chamber, or overload protection, which automatically shuts off the motor during a jam.

Once we pinpointed the disposals that stood out in these categories, we reviewed customer testimonials and expert opinions about them to determine whether or not they really are all they’re cracked up to be.

The Top 5 Best Garbage Disposals for the Practical Homeowner

And so, we have our list of the garbage disposals that will make your kitchen clean up (and your life) a whole lot easier.

This list should give you a few options if you are in the market for a disposal and make your search a lot shorter.

InSinkErator Evolution Excel 1.0

InSinkErator Garbage Disposal, Evolution Excel, 1.0 HP Continuous Feed
  • QUIET BUT POWERFUL: This innovative food waste disposal is the quietest...
  • AMERICA'S #1 DISPOSER BRAND: There are more American-built InSinkErator...

This is without a doubt one of the best possible garbage disposals you can buy. The InSinkErator Evolution Excel will continuously and reliably pulverize your food waste to smithereens.

This is thanks to its MultiGrind Technology that allows it to grind pretty much anything (except your silverware). Unlike other disposals, this one actually uses the full three stages for grinding, which makes it capable of handling meat, bones, or vegetables that tend to cause clogs.

It also has a 1 HP speed motor, which is pretty much the highest you can get when it comes to garbage disposals. But even though it’s powerful, it isn’t loud.

The Evolution Excel uses SoundSeal Technology to deliver ultra-quiet performance – so much so that it’s hard to even tell it’s even running until you notice that all the food scraps have disappeared.

To top it off, it even looks rather modern and sleek (though it of course will be completely hidden underneath your sink).

Moen GXP33C

Moen GXP33C Garbage Disposal
  • POWERFUL DISPOSAL: 1/3 horsepower vortex) motor is powerful enough to grind...
  • EASY-TO-INSTALL: Universal Xpress Mount fits Moen and most existing 3-bolt...
  • HIGH SPEED: disposals with 1900 RPM vortex) permanent magnet motor designed...

This quiet, stainless steel disposal won’t disappoint.

Moen has given us all a durable, effective and quiet garbage disposal with the GXS75C model. The 3/4 HP Vortex magnet motor has incredibly powerful grinding capabilities to ensure that no food scrap remains in your sink – and its high speed of 2700 RPM significantly reduces potential jamming.

And like the InSinkErator, it uses SoundShield technology to reduce noise without sacrificing performance.

One of the best aspects of this model is that it’s super easy to install. First of all, the power cord is pre-installed to save you time and money, and uses a Universal Xpress Mount three-bolt assembly. The only items you need to install are plumber’s paste and a wrench.

It also has a conveniently removable rubber splashguard so you can easily look down into the disposal chamber to check for any potential issues, and the drain plug has a shiny, attractive chrome cap instead of the not-so-elegant black rubber ones you often see.

Plus, this model is a great value considering how durable and powerful it is.

Waste King

Waste King L-3200 Garbage Disposal with Power Cord, 3/4 HP
  • COMPACT SIZE: Smaller and lighter ¾ HP design is 7-3/4 inches in diameter,...
  • HIGH-SPEED MOTOR: The 3/4 HP, 2700 RPM (115 volts) permanent magnet motor...
  • EASY INSTALLATION AND CLEANING: EZ Mount for a quick and easy kitchen sink...

For the best value, we recommend the L-3200 Legend Series disposal from Waste King.

At 3/4 HP, it’s a powerful food destructor that doesn’t make much noise (though it isn’t as quiet as the first two here) and jams far less than other garbage disposals in this price range.

It’s also incredibly lightweight, compact and durable with all stainless steel grinding components. In fact, one unique aspect of this disposal is that is has stainless steel swivel propellers that limit the amount of times it can clog.

Luckily it’s also very easy to install thanks to the EZ Mount and the pre-installed power cord – you could probably do it yourself if you felt comfortable enough. If you are confident enough to install it yourself, you’ll save a ton of money on top of the budget-friendly price of this disposal.

Finally, it’s safe for homes with septic tanks and comes with an amazing 8-year warranty that protects against corrosion, and mechanical and material defects. However, corrosion is unlikely since the interior chamber is made from glass-filled nylon.

InSinkErator PRO750

InSinkErator PRO750 Pro Series 3/4 HP Food Waste Disposal with...
  • This space-saving model is a perfect fit for restricted cabinet space
  • Sound Seal Makes the Evolution Essential at least 40% quieter than standard...
  • Multi Grind Two grind stages let you quickly grind difficult food waste

Yes, another InSinkErator model – but this time it’s the Badger 5 model.

This model features a galvanized steel grinding system, which perhaps isn’t as tough as stainless steel but still offers good grinding action. And, when combined with the company’s patented DuraDrive Technology, you can rest assured that all of your food waste is being adequately disposed. DuraDrive induction motors are long lasting and highly dependable, and it gives the grinding process an extra “oomph” of power that you can literally feel when you turn it on.

As for the actual grinding technology, the Badger 5 uses a GrindShear ring that basically liquefies all food waste – thus reducing the risk for clogging in your home’s sewer system.

But, the Quick Lock Technology really makes this model stand out. This installation uses a unique screw system that makes it incredibly easy to install – it’s almost like changing a light bulb and you can probably install it in under 25 minutes.

So, admittedly the motor power and grinding aren’t what make this one stand out. Sure, you’re going to have decent, reliable food waste disposal. But the true star of this garbage disposal is the Quick Lock feature.

Kitchen Aid

Kitchen Aid (84211643) KCDB250G 1/2 HP Continuous Feed Garbage...
  • Continuous feed allows for quick cleanup after meals
  • Motor rotates at 1725 rpm for effective grinding
  • Connected to an electrical switch for ease and safety

Though KitchenAid is best known for its iconic stand mixers, the company also knows a thing or two about food waste disposal.

This particular garbage disposal model is powerful, durable and efficient – and it’s backed by KitchenAid’s fantastic manufacture warranty.

This continuous feed disposal makes after-meal clean up very efficient and easy, especially with its 1/2 HP motor that achieves 1725 RPM. The blades and the grinding chamber are also crafted with stainless steel.

In short, the combination of the motor and the grinding mechanisms makes this a highly effective food disposal appliance.

KitchenAid also places a special focus on safety. It has a generously sized splashguard, rubber safety cap and a manual reset feature to keep all the fingers in your family safe. Plus, you have to turn it on using a switch (like many garbage disposals), which reduces the possibility of slicing off any digits.

It’s also a very affordable garbage disposal and it ranks quite favorably amongst consumers.

It perhaps isn’t as powerful or fancy as the others on this list, but it’s without a doubt a reliable and safe disposal – especially considering the price tag.

​A Garbage Disposal Buyer’s Guide

Ultimately, garbage disposals are rather straightforward appliances.

You don’t need to spend hours and hours researching to find the best garbage disposal for your home. The technology is simple enough that a lot of companies get it right.

So, the question then becomes more about your lifestyle.

Before you buy, think about the kind of food waste you create. If you eat a lot of meat or thick-skinned vegetables, then you may want to consider a more powerful disposal.

On the other hand, if your food waste primarily consists of light, organic substances (like maybe fruit scraps or water-heavy vegetables), then you probably don’t need a heavy-duty garbage disposal.

No matter what type of food waste you create, you mostly want to make sure that the grinding process is effective enough to prevent damage on your home sewer system.

The disposals listed here are widely praised amongst homeowners, and it’s likely you’ll see them recommended on a number of sites.

So though we suggest purchasing one of these five, there are also so many other garbage disposals out there that will do an excellent job and make a great addition to your kitchen.

And we hope that you never have to scoop soggy food out of the drain again!