Our Top 3 Picks for Best Mattresses – Buyer’s Guide


Nov 05

Out with the old, in with the new! We all know how it feels when you wake up with your back or neck aching… It’s not fun and could be a sign that it’s time to update your sleeping situation. Think about it, how long as it been since you last purchased a new pillow or even a new mattress?

Even the best mattresses have a lifespan guy! So, you should consider replacing it if it been quite a long while since you brought your current one home.

Here’s the problem with mattress shopping – you usually have to go to a store and be confronted by an eager sales rep that wants to find you the mattress of your dreams right there and then. They drag you through the showroom and make you awkwardly lay on a variety of mattresses until you finally tell them you’ll have to think on it a bit.

Sound familiar? Yea, we’ve been there too.

Which has inspired us to bring you a list of what we consider to be the top three best mattresses for your consideration!

Purchasing Mattresses Can Be a Hassle

mattress queen

Shopping for a new mattress can be a hassle, and we aren’t only referring to those awkward sales reps from earlier.

Shoppers are faced with hundreds of options and two ways to purchase:

  • Online
  • In-store

While both options are great in their ways, they both provide obstacles for shoppers.

When buying in-store, those sales representatives are breathing down your neck, you feel awkward trying out all the mattresses, and many have a hard time doing even that because of the thought of who tried it before you is bound to be in the back of your head.

However, if you decide to shop online, the biggest obstacle is not being able to test out the mattress to see what would best suit your personal needs.

It really can feel like a loss-loss situation! So instead of going in blindly, we’ve put together a handy buyer’s guide to help you find the best mattresses that will suit your needs.

A Buyer’s Guide for Picking Their Ideal Mattresses

When it comes to shopping for anything, whether it be online or in-store, you need to know what it is you want - or at least have a good idea.

That’s why we decided to take the time to put together some things shoppers will want to consider before they head out to the store or begin surging the web.

Types of Mattresses

nice mattress

When you start your shopping process, the very first thing you’ll need to decide on is what type of mattress will best suit you and your partner’s needs.

There are a few different types of mattresses currently available, and we’ve listed them for you below:

Innerspring Mattresses

These are the most traditional mattresses on the market. They are filled with steel coils in a variety of different configurations. These configurations can include different layers of cushioning, infused gel, and even a pillowtop layer.

Foam Mattresses

Foam mattresses are made of either polyurethane foams or latex. These tend to be softer mattresses overall, and they mold more to the body once the user has gotten on it. After the user gets back up, the foam springs back to the original shape.

Adjustable Air Mattresses

These mattresses are often used for those special guests that need a place to crash. They are inflated to the user’s desired level of firmness with the use of an electric pump that tends to be rather noisy when in use.

It is worth noting that these mattresses often don’t come with extra layers to them, but they can come with a layer of foam on the top for added comfort.

Hybrid Mattresses

Hybrid mattresses are the newest on the market, and they usually include some combination of both innerspring mattresses and foam. Usually, users get the support of an innerspring with the comfort of a foam top layer.


Let’s face it; some people sleep warmer than others. That being said, some mattresses help to regulate the heat retention of the mattress to help those who sleep warmer sleep more comfortably.

Look for mattresses that offer advanced foams and ventilation. Some even come with a cool-to-the-touch gel-foam layer that may be worth looking into.

Overall Support & Comfort

​​​Support and overall comfort are the whole reason most people decide to replace their mattress, so this is an area that shoppers should pay special attention to.

This is something that is easier to judge by heading out to the store simply because you can test out how the mattress supports you while you are resting on it.

You want a mattress that holds you in proper alignment because this will eliminate those mornings where you wake up with neck and back pains. You also don’t want your mattress to cause a lot of pressure on your joints and body overall. So again, this is best tested by trying mattress in-store.

However, if you are buying online, you can consider the mattress firmness. If you know what type of mattress best suits your body, looking at the overall firmness can help you better judge online.

Soft Mattresses

If you were to rate a mattress on a scale of 1 - 10 as far as how firm it is, then a soft mattress would fall somewhere between a 3 and 5. Being that they are softer in nature, they tend to have greater give to them, and users can test this by how much they “sink” into the mattress when they lay on it.

Side sleepers tend to prefer a softer mattress then those that lay on their stomach or back.

Medium Mattresses

Medium firmness is often described as a level between 6 or 7 out of 10. There is a little bit o “sinkage” when a user sits or lays on it but is noticeably firmer when compared to a soft mattress.

Back sleepers and side sleepers tend to enjoy a medium firm mattress, though back sleepers tend to enjoy them more than side sleepers who prefer the extra “hug” from a softer mattress.

Firm Mattresses

Firm mattresses have very minimal sinkage to them, and they tend to fall anywhere between a 7.5 and 9 on the firmness scale.

Stomach sleepers tend to prefer anywhere from a medium to the firm level mattress, though it seems as if the firmer, the better for some.

Universal Comfort Mattresses

Universal comfort mattresses are made to suit the overall needs of the “average” sleeper. Users often describe universal mattresses as ranging in a medium firmness range, though these mattresses are also known to react to the user’s body in a way that feels comfortable from all angles.

These mattresses also tend to feature a foam layer to aid in the overall comfort level of the mattress. They would average between a 5 and 7 on the firmness scale.

Motion Tran​​​​sfer

Motion transfer is important to consider if you co-sleep with your partner. When there are two people in a bed, let’s face it, there is going to be some motion transfer when one gets up in the middle of the night to go to the washroom.

Some mattresses do their best to minimize this transfer of motion with the use of extra padding or with a gel insert. The best way to judge motion transfer is to try out the mattress in store with your partner. Both of you should lay down and one at a time, each of you tries getting up and back into bed and change position while in the bed.

Edge Support

Edge support, loosely defined, is the encasement around the edge of the mattress. They are required for many innerspring mattresses to support the springs. Some mattresses simply use a metal rod while others use a special foam padding that helps to prevent mattress-edge sinking that tends to happen when a user sits at the edge of the bed.

This is especially important to consider if you tend to sleep closer to the edge of the bed at night. You want something with good edge support so that your mattress doesn’t sink under you and you end up on the floor.


Yes, as with any big-ticket item, you want to check the warranty of your mattress. In most cases, they can range between 10 and 25 years, and they tend to cover only manufacturing defects such as broken coil wires and sagging.

Customer Reviews

This is particularly important to consider if you are purchasing a mattress online and are unable to try-before-you-buy.

In most cases, customer reviews are honest and will give you a good overall rating of the bed. This may sound a little cynical but avoid reading too many overly happy reviews simply because you don’t know if that may have been a paid review or if they received something in return for a positive post.

Now, that doesn’t mean ignore all good reviews! You’ll be able to tell the difference between a sponsored “OMG THIS IS PERFECT” review and an honest review from a pleased customer.

Overall Budget

Know what you want to spend! We can’t stress this enough!

Mattresses can range widely depending on where you buy it from, so know what your budget is before you start shopping. Depending on the features and if you need a new bedspring or not, the price can easily go from a couple of hundred dollars to a few thousand.

How We Chose Our Ranking

When it comes down to ranking products for our readers, we take the time to look into the product, the company name, and what fellow consumers have had to say.

That being said, when choosing our rankings, we considered the above factors and tallied up totals to reach an overall ranking, which we’ve listed below each product as a star rating.

Our Top 3 Picks for Best Mattresses

After doing our research into different brands and mattresses and looking at what consumers had to say, we were able to narrow down the top three brands for best mattresses overall.

Instead of selecting individual mattresses, we decided to look at brands that provided the best options for the most sleepers and then compared that to what consumers had to say.

After tallying up our totals, these brands made the top three cut:

Nectar Queen Mattress + 2 Free Pillows - Gel Memory Foam - CertiPUR-US...

4.7 of 5 stars

Nectar is an online mattress retailer that states they have “aligned all” their “efforts around one simple promise: the best sleep of your life, guaranteed.”

Despite being one of the newest companies in the mattress business, having only opened its doors in 2017, it has quickly become a favorite for those looking for quality sleep on quality mattresses at a lower cost when compared to other top brands.

They offer a variety of mattresses that are made with the best certified flexible foam; they are also said to be the some of the best when it comes to temperature regulation, air circulation, and weight distribution.

Price Range: $524.00 - $924.00

Amerisleep AS5 14' Memory Foam Mattress (Queen)

4.6 of 5 stars

Amerisleep is an online mattress retailer that boats to providing “a revitalizing rest with technologically advanced, American-made, eco-friendly mattresses. While shoppers can purchase from the online store, there are also a handful of retail locations for shoppers that feel the need to test before they buy.

They provide a variety of different mattresses to suit the needs of not only back, side and stomach sleepers, but also those that fall under the “combo” category. They also feature two different collections – The Firm Collection and The Soft Collection and provide helpful tips to help guide shoppers.

Price Range: $1,199.00 - $2,099.00

Casper Sleep Foam Mattress, King 10'

4.3 of 5 stars

When people think of the “bed in a box” trend, Casper is one of the top names that come to mind. While they do have some retail locations, they are known for delivering your new mattress wrapped up in a nice little box right to your doorstep.

Depending on the mattress that the individual needs, there are three different collections:

  • The 3-layer collection – The Essential
  • The 4-layer collection – The Casper
  • The 5-layer collection – The Wave

Each collection features a given amount of foam layers to it to suit the individual needs for each sleeper.

Price Range: $350.00 - $2,750.00

When Looking at the Best Mattresses, Take Your Time

mattress white

Once it has been decided that it’s time to purchase a new mattress, combing through the best mattresses can be very overwhelming.

That being said, keep in mind our handy buyer’s guide and don’t rush the shopping process. Take your time to find what works for you, so you spend the money where you need it most.

Happy shopping!